Posted in Assault on Science, Climate Science, Denier Culture, tagged Climate Change, CRU Hack, Exposing Deniers, Global Warming, Hide the decline, Republicans, Richard Muller, tree ring proxy on April 26, 2011|
28 Comments »
Knowledge is a deadly friend
When no one sets the rules.
The fate of all mankind I see
Is in the hands of fools.
Let me begin by saying I have enormous respect for William M. Connolley (aka Stoat) and generally do not significantly disagree with him.
However, in his Apr 5th piece “Muller is rubbish” Stoat said “But he [Muller] isn’t a tosser.”
Stoat, you’re just plain wrong, Muller most definitely is a well bad tosser, a “denialist chumming complete bollocks.”
(more documentation at bottom)
Richard Muller is a Berkeley physicist of some minor notoriety in climate change circles for being critical of “the Hockey Stick” (ie historical temperature reconstructions). By “critical” I mean calling it “phoney.”
Earlier this year the Berkeley Earth Surface Temperature group began a project to re-examine the existing temperature data. The project drew criticism for, among other things:
- consisting exclusively of people with a poor track record for:
being funded in part by Koch Industries.
- discussing the science honestly.
- actually understanding the science.
On March 31 Muller testified before Congress and affirmed the high quality of the existing climate science which sent the climate change Deniers into a frenzy.
The Muller sideshow has been one I have been largely ignoring, but then a repeat commenter brought this video clip to my attention:
Read Full Post »
Posted in Activism, Assault on Science, Climate Change, Politics, tagged Activism, Climate Change, cummings, Global Warming, Nonviolent resistance, Political Action, Republicans on April 11, 2011|
3 Comments »
Simple people,people who don’t exist,prefer things which don’t exist,simple things.
e.e. cummings; six nonlectures
Al Gore had a few minor errors of no particular consequence in his movie “An Inconvenient Truth“, but his book “The Assault on Reason” was wildly wrong in at least two important respects:
i) The internet has proven to be a far more useful tool for the climate change Deniers than it has for the science fact community. This is undoubtedly because it is easier to tweet simple things such as “If
evolution climate change is real, why are there still monkeys snowstorms?” than it is to understand the facts.
Not that the explanation is that complex, just that it takes more than 140 characters to say and a bit of actual thinking to understand.
ii) What we are witnessing is not an “Assault on Reason”, it is the wholesale abandonment of reason. Democracy requires dialogue, a dialogue that simply isn’t happening, and quite possibly cannot happen when one of the camps has chosen paranoid delusions and willful stupidity as their coping mechanisms.
Read Full Post »
Posted in Assault on Science, Climate Change, Politics, tagged Christopher Monckton, Climate Change, climate change Deniers, Climate Justice, Denier Culture, Exposing Deniers, Global Warming, Political Action, Politics, Republicans on April 5, 2011|
8 Comments »
Parse that carefully because it can be too easy to become focused on the “Stupid” part. It’s S-t-u-p-i-d W-h-i-t-e M-e-n.
For completeness we should add “Old”, and “Rich” (and probably some other adjectives as well) because of course in addition to being a race and gender issue climate change is a class and generational one. Having said that, it is a very particular brand of ‘Stupid’ that we are dealing with and it deserves dissection.
Nowhere is this clearer than the recent U.S. Congressional House Energy and Commerce Committee vote that denied the existence of climate change. As has been noted elsewhere, they may as well have voted to deny the existence of gravity. While I have been known to compare climate change Denier‘s intelligence to that of lobotomized rodents it is still breathtaking to see them literally taking it to that level.
Read Full Post »